In reality, however, "Carry On" has been described an anti-climactic finish that didn't come close to matching the hype.
The brothers were the beating heart of Supernatural, and ending the show with a Winchester-centric episode could have been an appropriate way to bid farewell after 15 years.
Supernatural boldly chose to forego the usual TV finale format - virtually every plot thread was already tied off in the penultimate episode, leaving one final hour to focus entirely on Sam and Dean Winchester. Here are the biggest points of contention among fans. There are certainly positives to be found (mostly within the performances of Jensen Ackles and Jared Padalecki, predictably), but the criticism of "Carry On" is louder than the acclaim.
Generally speaking, fan response to Supernatural's ending has been a mixture of bitter disappointment and lukewarm indifference. The build to Supernatural's finale had already proved controversial due to the death of a major character and a surprisingly simple battle against Chuck. The closing episode itself, titled "Carry On," would continue walking that divisive path. Related: Supernatural's Future Explained: Spinoffs, Revival, What's Next? Supernatural season 15 was interrupted due to the coronavirus pandemic, but returned in October 2020 for a concluding string of episodes. Sam and Dean were faced with a host of old villains after Chuck opened the gates of hell, and once the satanic orifice was finally closed shut, a cataclysmic battle against the Almighty awaited. In an emotional announcement video, Supernatural season 15 was confirmed to be the Winchesters' final run, and the premiere kicked off proceedings in grand fashion. Unfortunately, Supernatural is feeling the wrong end of that passion following the long-awaited finale episode. Audiences watched Sam and Dean grow from fresh-faced boys to fully-grown men, and Supernatural's fandom became one of the most loyal and passionate in TV.
Thanks to the chemistry between Supernatural's leading duo, Eric Kripke's epic tale of family and fantasy lasted longer than anybody thought possible, and the Winchesters' journey ultimately spanned a full 15 seasons. Why has online reaction to the Supernaturalseries finale been predominantly negative so far? Launching in 2005, Supernatural told the story of two sibling monster hunters, Sam and Dean Winchester, who began hunting vampires, werewolves and wendigos, and worked their way up to Lucifer, the archangel Michael, and God himself.